How to Build a Target List for Buy-Side M&A

Buy-Side

Target List

How to Build a Target List for Buy-Side M&A

Acquiring a company is a complex process filled with risk, and identifying the right targets is a critical first step. While the approach can vary, a clear and strategic method for building your acquisition list is essential. Though simplified, the process involves more than just identifying companies—it requires thoughtful filtering and evaluation. Fortunately, today's data-driven tools make it easier to compile and assess high-quality targets quickly and effectively, allowing acquirers to make informed decisions with greater confidence.

Horizontal Integration

When a company pursues horizontal integration, it typically focuses on acquiring businesses within the same industry and geographic region—areas where it already has operational knowledge. This often includes product lines or services closely aligned with its current offerings. As a result, the acquirer usually has insight into key competitors or ideal targets within the niche. To make informed decisions, it’s essential to understand competitor market share and evaluate the overall growth potential within the sector. This familiarity helps reduce risk and maximize strategic value in the acquisition.

Market Extension

This approach focuses on entering new geographic markets that align with your company’s growth strategy. Begin by identifying and ranking potential markets based on desirability and strategic fit. It’s important to assess how acquisition compares to organic entry in each market—considering speed, cost, and impact. Evaluating the potential market share that could be captured through acquisition can help prioritize targets and guide expansion decisions effectively.

Vertical Backward Integration

In a backward integration strategy, a company looks to acquire suppliers or upstream partners in its value chain. The goal is to create synergies, reduce costs, and gain more control over inputs. By evaluating your own supply dependencies—and those of competitors—you can identify strategic acquisition targets that strengthen your operational foundation and add long-term value.

Vertical Forward Integration

Forward integration involves acquiring businesses closer to the end customer—typically distributors, retailers, or direct service channels. To evaluate this strategy, companies should analyze customer acquisition methods both by industry and by individual relationships. This is especially relevant when dominant customers or market leaders hold significant influence over distribution or access.

However, caution is warranted: smaller acquisitions made primarily to secure access to large customers may pose risks such as customer concentration. In such cases, a discounted valuation may be appropriate to account for potential instability.

Product/Service Extension

This strategy focuses on expanding the company’s current offerings by acquiring complementary products or services. By mapping what existing customers purchase from competitors or outside vendors, companies can identify valuable opportunities for upselling, cross-selling, or enhancing service bundles.

These types of acquisitions are often most effective when made within the same geographic area, simplifying integration and accelerating results. A thoughtful analysis of customer needs and competitor gaps can help prioritize which offerings to bring in-house through acquisition.

Free-Form Acquisition

Free-form diversification refers to acquiring businesses in entirely new markets—whether by geography, industry, or offering—where the buyer has little or no prior involvement. These opportunities don’t fit neatly into traditional strategic categories and often involve the highest level of risk due to unfamiliarity and lack of internal capability. However, despite the uncertainty, such targets can still be valuable additions to an M&A pipeline when approached with clear objectives and thorough due diligence. They represent bold moves toward innovation or long-term strategic transformation.

While it may be tempting to immediately dismiss acquisition targets that don't meet initial criteria, it’s often wiser to keep all potential options in play throughout the evaluation process. Growth opportunities and strategic fit can emerge unexpectedly, especially from unconventional or “free-form” targets that may reveal hidden synergies or lower-than-expected risk upon closer analysis.

To guide prioritization, consider ranking each target using both qualitative and quantitative metrics—such as strategic alignment, cultural fit, financial performance, and integration complexity. Remember, the softer elements—like company culture—can have a greater impact on deal success than numbers alone.

Engaging an experienced M&A advisor can be invaluable in uncovering the right fit, navigating complexities, and ensuring execution is both strategic and efficient.

Delivering measurable value

Reduced time-to-market

50%

Foresight accelerates your market entry, cutting product launch times by half through efficient strategy and execution.

Increase in operational efficiency

75%

Streamlined processes and expert guidance boost your operational efficiency by 75%, ensuring smoother and faster workflows.

Better green credentials

37%

Foresight cuts your carbon footprint while boosting product sell-through via AI and efficient data use.

Retain your prized talent

85%